SoVote

Bill C-270

44th Parl. 1st Sess.

May 08, 2024

Bill C-270 is a proposed law that would make changes to the Criminal Code regarding pornographic material. It would prohibit the making, distribution, or advertising of pornographic material for commercial purposes without first ensuring that everyone depicted in the material is 18 years of age or older and has given their consent to be depicted. Violators could face fines up to $500,000 or imprisonment for up to two years. The bill also includes provisions for verifying the age of participants and allowing for orders to be made to restrict internet use or remove material.

A steelman argument in favor of Bill C-270 would be that it is necessary to protect individuals from exploitation and harm within the pornographic industry. By requiring explicit consent from all individuals depicted in pornographic material and ensuring that they are 18 years of age or older, the bill aims to prevent non-consensual and underage participation in the production and distribution of pornographic content. This is important for safeguarding vulnerable individuals, particularly minors, who may be coerced or forced into participating in pornographic material without their consent. Additionally, the bill introduces penalties for those who fail to comply with these requirements, which serves as a deterrent to potential offenders. By implementing these measures, Bill C-270 contributes to creating a safer and more ethical pornographic industry.

A steelman argument opposing this bill could be as follows: Protecting freedom of expression and personal autonomy should be prioritized over restricting the production and distribution of pornographic material. While it is important to ensure that individuals are not exploited or harmed in the process of creating pornographic material, criminalizing the production, distribution, and advertising of such material without explicit consent and age verification places unnecessary restrictions on the adult entertainment industry. 1. Freedom of expression: Pornography, when created consensually, is a form of expression and should be protected under the principle of freedom of speech. By prohibiting the creation and distribution of pornographic material without explicit consent, the government is infringing on the right to express oneself sexually and limiting the diversity of content available to adult consumers. 2. Protection of personal