SoVote

Bill C-223

44th Parl. 1st Sess.

February 13, 2024

Bill C-223 aims to create a national framework for a guaranteed livable basic income in Canada. The Minister of Finance would be responsible for developing this framework, which would provide all individuals over the age of 17 with access to a guaranteed livable basic income. The framework would be developed in consultation with various stakeholders, including representatives from the health, employment, social development, and disability sectors, as well as Indigenous elders and governing bodies. The framework would include measures to determine what constitutes a livable basic income, create national standards for health and social supports, ensure that participation in education or the labor market is not required for eligibility, and maintain services and benefits for individuals with exceptional needs. The Minister would be required to prepare a report on the framework within one year of the Act coming into force, and subsequent re

A steelman argument in favor of this bill could be framed as follows: Implementing a guaranteed livable basic income (GLBI) through a national framework is a necessary step to address poverty, income inequality, and the social and economic challenges of the present time. By ensuring that all individuals over the age of 17 have access to a certain level of income, the GLBI program will contribute to eradicating poverty and improving the overall well-being of the population. One of the main benefits of a GLBI program is its potential to promote income equality and reduce disparities. By providing a minimum level of income for all individuals, regardless of their employment status, the program can create a more equitable society. This can lead to improved social cohesion and reduce the socioeconomic divisions that currently exist, ultimately fostering a more inclusive and just society. Additionally, the GLBI program can have significant

Steelman Argument: Opposing Bill C-223 - An Act to Develop a National Framework for a Guaranteed Livable Basic Income While the intentions behind Bill C-223 are noble, there are several concerns and potential drawbacks that should be considered. Firstly, implementing a guaranteed livable basic income program may create discouragement towards work and hinder economic growth. By providing a guaranteed income without any requirements for individuals to participate in education, training, or the labor market, it may disincentivize individuals from seeking employment or pursuing higher education. This could lead to a decrease in productivity and a potential drain on the economy, as individuals may be more inclined to rely solely on the basic income without seeking additional sources of income. Furthermore, funding such a program on a national scale may be a significant financial burden on the government. The cost of implementing and sust