SoVote

Bill S-233

44th Parl. 1st Sess.

April 18, 2023

Summary: This bill, titled "An Act to develop a national framework for a guaranteed livable basic income," requires the Minister of Finance to create a plan to provide all individuals over the age of 17 in Canada with access to a guaranteed livable basic income. The bill also includes reporting requirements for the framework. The purpose of this bill is to address poverty, income inequality, health conditions, and educational outcomes while ensuring the well-being and security of all individuals in Canada. The Minister of Finance must consult with various stakeholders and experts in developing the framework, which will determine what constitutes a livable basic income for each region, create national standards for health and social supports, and ensure participation in education or the labor market is not required. The Minister is also required to submit reports to Parliament outlining the framework and its effectiveness.

Steelman Argument in Favor of Bill S-233: The development of a national framework for a guaranteed livable basic income, as proposed in Bill S-233, is an important and necessary step towards addressing poverty and inequality in Canada. It recognizes that every person should have access to a livable basic income, which can help alleviate poverty, improve health conditions, and enhance educational outcomes. By implementing a guaranteed livable basic income program, individuals, families, and communities will benefit. It will provide financial security for those who are made most vulnerable in society and protect them from the hardships caused by poverty. This program will ensure that all individuals in Canada have the necessary resources to lead a dignified and healthy life. Furthermore, a guaranteed livable basic income program, implemented through a national framework, can contribute to addressing major challenges such as the climate

Steelman Argument Opposing Bill S-233: While the intentions behind implementing a guaranteed livable basic income are noble, there are several potential drawbacks and concerns with Bill S-233. First and foremost, the implementation of such a program would require significant financial resources. This would likely result in increased taxes or government spending, which could have negative economic consequences such as stifled economic growth and job creation. Additionally, the introduction of a guaranteed livable basic income may disincentivize individuals from seeking employment and pursuing higher education. If individuals are provided with a guaranteed income regardless of their employment status, there may be less motivation to work or seek education and training opportunities to improve their skills and job prospects. This could ultimately lead to a decline in productivity and a dependence on government support. Furthermore, th